Solving Denver’s Fence Repair Dilemma
If you live in Denver, you know how tough the weather can be on a fence. A strong gust of wind, a heavy snow season, or years of sun exposure can leave it warped, cracked, or leaning. When that happens, most homeowners face the same question: Should I repair it, or is it time to replace it?
With more than 18 years of experience helping Denver-area homeowners, Andrew-Thomas Contractors has seen just about every fence problem imaginable. Our mission is simple: give you honest, expert advice and deliver solutions that last.
We’re here seven days a week, 7 am to 8 pm, ready to help you reclaim your peace of mind and your property’s curb appeal.
There’s no need to guess, schedule a free expert assessment. We’ll guide you through every step so you can make a confident decision that protects your home for years to come.
The Homeowner’s Dilemma—Repair or Replace? (The 20-50% Rule)
Facing a damaged fence? Choosing between repair and replacement can be tricky. Let’s break down how to make a cost-effective, long-lasting decision.
Here’s the industry standard we use to guide our Denver clients:
The 20-50% Rule
- Repair: If the cost to repair your fence is less than 20% of the replacement cost, fixing it is usually the smarter move.
- Replace: If repairs reach 40–50% of the cost of a new fence, investing in replacement is generally the better long-term choice.
But it’s not just about the numbers, the type of damage matters too:
Acute Damage (Repair)
- Localized, recent issues like a single broken post, a few cracked pickets, or a wobbly gate after a backyard soccer game.
- If the rest of your fence is solid, targeted repairs can add years to its life.
Chronic Damage (Replace)
- Widespread rot, severe warping across multiple sections, deep rust, or several leaning posts.
- These are signs that the fence’s overall structure is failing and replacement is the safer, more durable option.
We’ll always walk you through this calculation, with complete transparency, so you can make a confident, informed choice.
When Fence Repair Is the Smart, Cost-Effective Solution
Signs Your Fence Is a Good Candidate for Repair
Not every worn or damaged fence needs to be replaced. Fence repair is often the smarter, more cost-effective choice when:
- Your fence is relatively new (under 5–10 years old).
- Damage is limited to a small area (less than 20% of the total fence).
- The core structure; posts and rails are still strong and stable.
Repair Tips by Material
- Wood:
Cracked or missing pickets, loose rails, or a gate that’s not closing right? These are classic repair jobs. - Vinyl/Composite:
One or two damaged panels, minor cracks, or cosmetic fading can often be patched or replaced seamlessly. - Metal/Iron:
Isolated rust spots, a bent rail, or a loose post? Targeted repairs and a fresh coat of paint can restore both function and appearance.
Our fence repairs aren’t just “patch jobs.” Andrew-Thomas Contractors uses high-quality materials and professional techniques to ensure every repair lasts not just limps along.
Common Fence Repairs in Denver
We’ve seen it all in our area, but here are the repairs we handle most often:
- Wood Fences:
- Replacing individual pickets or boards
- Reattaching or reinforcing loose rails
- Fixing or upgrading gate hardware
- Treating and sealing exposed wood
- Vinyl/Composite Fences:
- Swapping out cracked or broken panels
- Cleaning away mildew and stains
- Minor patching for chips or holes
- Metal/Iron Fences:
- Sanding and repainting rust spots
- Welding minor cracks or breaks
- Straightening bent sections
What Makes ATC Repairs Last Longer
We use premium-grade materials, set posts deeper for stability, and never cut corners because that’s exactly what we’d want for our own homes.
The ATC Repair Process—Transparent, Local, Reliable
Here’s how we make the process easy and stress-free:
- Thorough Inspection:
We start with a detailed look at your fence, identifying not just what’s broken, but why it happened. - Transparent Estimate:
You get a clear, written estimate with options. - Quality Repair:
Our experienced team handles every fix with care, using the best materials and proven techniques. - Follow-Up:
We check back after the job to ensure you’re completely satisfied and share maintenance tips to keep your fence strong.
“Our clients appreciate that we treat their property like our own. We communicate every step, so there are no surprises, just results.”
When Fence Replacement Is the Best Investment
Knowing When to Say Goodbye—Fence Age & Lifespan
Even the highest-quality fence won’t last forever. Based on what we see across Denver:
- Wood Fences: 15–20 years
- Vinyl Fences: 25+ years
If your fence is approaching or has passed these benchmarks, repairs may only provide a temporary fix. At this point, investing in a full fence installation/replacement is usually the smarter, longer-lasting solution.
Structural Failures That Signal Replacement
Some issues just can’t be fixed for the long haul:
- Post Failure:
Leaning or rotting posts mean the foundation is compromised. In Denver, we see this a lot after freeze-thaw cycles. - Widespread Warping or Rot:
When more than a few sections are affected, the structural integrity is gone. - Multiple Failing Sections:
If you’re fixing something new every year, it’s time to consider a fresh start.
The Hidden Costs of Patchwork Repairs
It’s tempting to keep fixing one section at a time, but this can lead to:
- A mismatched, “patchwork” appearance
- Ongoing maintenance headaches
- Lower property value
- Higher long-term costs
A new fence, on the other hand, comes with a warranty and peace of mind.
Replacement as an Upgrade Opportunity
Replacing your fence isn’t just about fixing a problem, it’s a chance to:
- Boost curb appeal and property value
- Upgrade to modern, low-maintenance materials
- Improve privacy and security
- Match your home’s updated style
We’ll walk you through all your options, from classic wood to high-tech composites, so your new fence fits your needs and your budget.
Denver-Specific Fence Problems & Solutions
Frost Heave—Denver’s Biggest Fence Enemy
Denver’s freeze-thaw cycles are notorious for shifting fence posts and causing misalignment. It’s not your fault,it’s just part of living here.
How we solve it:
- We set posts deeper than the standard, using more concrete for stability.
- When we replace a fence, we use techniques proven to withstand Denver winters.
High-Altitude UV Damage & Weathering
Denver’s intense sunlight can fade and crack both wood and vinyl much faster than in other places.
What to look for:
- Fading, graying, or splintering wood
- Brittle or cracked vinyl panels
Our advice:
- If the damage is mostly cosmetic, a professional cleaning or stain may do the trick.
- If the material is brittle or breaking, it’s likely time for replacement.
Wind & Storm Damage—Insurance and Fast Repairs
Denver’s winds can take out multiple fence sections at once. If more than 20% of your fence is damaged, you may be eligible for insurance coverage.
Tips:
- Take clear photos of all damage.
- Contact your insurance company promptly.
- Andrew-Thomas Contractors assists with documentation and estimates to support your claim
Serving All of Denver—Local Expertise, Neighborhood Insights
We have been serving Denver and the surrounding communities for over 15 years. We know the neighborhoods, the soil, and the weather patterns. Our local experience and areas served mean we can spot issues others might miss.
“We’ve built and repaired fences in nearly every Denver neighborhood. Our clients trust us because we know the local challenges and we stand behind our work.”
Why Choose Andrew-Thomas Contractors for Your Fence Repair or Replacement?
The ATC Difference—Experience, Materials, and Transparency
Here’s what sets us apart:
- Over 18 Years Serving the Denver Metro Area: Our local expertise means we understand neighborhood conditions, soil types, and weather challenges that affect fences.
- Large Business Quality, Small Business Care: We deliver professional, high-standard results while treating every client like family.
- Transparent, Honest Recommendations: We guide you toward the solution that’s right for your home and budget.
- Premium Materials and Proven Techniques: From posts to panels, we use top-quality materials and construction methods built to last.
- Customer-First Philosophy: We treat your property like our own, ensuring every repair or replacement meets our high standards.
“We believe in doing the job right the first time. Our reputation is built on trust, and we never take shortcuts.”
What to Expect—Our 4-Step Transparent Process
- Inspection
We assess the entire fence, not just the obvious damage. Our team checks posts, panels, gates, and hardware to identify both visible and hidden issues, giving you a full picture of your fence’s condition. - Estimate
You receive a clear, detailed quote outlining all repair or replacement options. We explain the costs, materials, and timeline, so you can make an informed, confident decision. - Execution
Our skilled team completes the work efficiently, cleanly, and safely. We treat your property with respect, using premium materials and proven techniques to ensure long-lasting results. - Follow-Up
After the job is done, we check in to make sure you’re completely satisfied. We answer any questions and provide maintenance tips to keep your fence in top shape for years to come.
We empower you with knowledge and options, so you can make the best decision for your home.
Availability & Service Area
We’re here when you need us, seven days a week, from 7 am to 8 pm. If you have an urgent repair, we do our best to respond quickly, so your home and family stay secure.
Fence Repair in Denver- Frequently Asked Questions
How long do repairs take?
Most repairs are completed in a single day, but larger jobs or full replacements may take longer. We’ll always give you a clear timeline up front.
What materials do you use?
We use only premium-grade wood, vinyl, and metal, chosen for durability in Denver’s climate.
Can you match my existing fence?
Absolutely. We do our best to match styles and materials so repairs blend seamlessly.
Is there a warranty?
Yes. All our repairs and new installations come with a warranty for your peace of mind.
How do I get an estimate?
Just give us a call, fill out our online form, or send us an email. Estimates are always free and no-obligation.
Do you help with insurance?
Yes, we can provide documentation and guidance to help with your insurance claim.
Get Your Free, Expert Fence Assessment Today
If your fence needs attention, we can help. Whether it’s a minor repair or a full replacement, our team serves the Denver Metro area with reliable, professional service and we’ll provide a free estimate before any work begins.
Contact Andrew-Thomas Contractors:
- Phone: 303-434-7926
- Web Form: Contact Page
- Email: sales@at-contractors.com
Office Hours:
- Mon–Fri: 7am–5pm
- Sat: 8am–12pm
Experience the ATC difference, Denver’s trusted choice for fence repair and replacement.
Written by Kyle Fletcher
Kyle Fletcher is the owner and CEO of Andrew‑Thomas Contractors, serving the Denver metro. In fencing since high school, he launched the company in 2006 and oversees estimating, scheduling, and quality checks on residential, commercial, and HOA projects. His team specializes in fence installation and repair, driveway gates, hand rails, and safety bollards, delivering work at or above industry standards. Clients know Kyle for clear communication and clean job sites—habits reflected in the firm’s A+ BBB rating and consistently strong Google reviews.